Why 4 stars? Because it was our go-to for convenience.
--- --- ---
I was staying at my Grandmother's house in Broadview Heights for about a week during the NBA Finals. Broadview Heights is not exactly a haven for local business, and Romeo's is located conveniently on the way to I-77 from my grandma's house. Because of all of those factors, we probably ended up here 3 or 4 times during my Cleveland trip.
We actually only had pizza one time, and went with sandwiches on all the other visits. Each sandwich and pizza that I tried was the definition of 4-stars: solid. Not bad, not amazing, but solid.
But again, the convenience factor is strong here. We would call 15 minutes ahead, and our food would be waiting for us upon arrival. If you're looking for the convenience of fast food, without the low quality, Romeo's is your answer.