Alright, so I've been to Lidia's a few times now and everytime I go, I get less and less impressed.
The first time was great and I really enjoyed my meal (and the price). However, after going back and getting the same dish and ALSO trying their brunch- I would have to say that Lidia's wasn't as good as I originally thought it was.
I personally find the pre-fixe brunch menu over priced, simply because you can get better brunch pre-fixe menus around the area for the same price.
The pastas are OK- but I guess the last time I went it didn't taste as good as the first time! (I got the almond pesto spaghetti). The decor is great and I would say that the huge bar is most definitely impressive.
Hopefully the next time I go back (if there is a next time) my opinion will change.