The only reason for the 3/5 is for the service...
When walking in we were told we had to pay $1 for a lifetime membership (call it what it is a cover charge) by a very persnickety hostess who than told us to "sit anywhere". Only a few chairs at the bar so we opted for a table next to the bar.
Our server was darling! Though not versed in the food specials she knew her beverages (but being a bar I gave her a pass).
The selection for a whiskey bar was really poor - basically any avid whiskey drinker would have selection in their home stash! The mixed drinks were however really well made and tasted great.
The food selection was austere and what we ordered was okay.
They need a bigger menu (sandwiches need to come with a side other than pickles) with variety!
For the cost of our meal we got a poor selection of drink, food and so so atmosphere.