Three stars feels exactly right. I live nearby and visit sporadically. If it were the quality of Burritos Banditos I'd be saying I was a regular but it's just not that kind of good yet.
The quality of the food overall is decent. The quality of the meat isn't the best though primarily with the chicken. Passable for most but if you've had any good traditional stuff you can taste the difference. It's a few pegs above subway's microwaveable chicken but it still doesn't have that fresh unprocessed taste. And to echo a lot of past reviews AVOID THE COLESLAW.
I tend to lean towards the battered fish & shrimp mix as their best burrito. Unfortunately for the smaller foodies it only comes in huge ($13).
The service is timely and most of their staff is friendly and careful about preparing your burrito. One particular member of the crew is mysteriously hostile when talking to men. Don't what that's about but on the bright side I see her the least.
All in all this is a nice on the run burrito place if you have 10-15 waiting on the prep. It's good every time but not great often.
If you want to find the best burritos in the city take your search elsewhere.
UPDATE: They now do the Shrimp mix in all sizes! (2015)