Fantastic little restaurant. Been there twice now, though others in my family are regulars. It has quickly become my favorite place to eat in Mentor. The wait staff is very friendly and accommodating. They even gave us some free desert and soup this time just because they like my mother so much.
The first time I went I had the chicken parmesan, which was delicious (a staple and test of mine when trying new Italian places). This time I had the aglio olio and it was equally delicious. Others in my family tried some of their pizzas, which were also fantastic, and tonight my mother had the prime rib, which was one of their specials. In her words it was "some of the best she'd had in a long time." Their appetizers and desserts are also extremely delicious.
If you haven't tried this place yet you need to. Some of the best food in town and it's nice and local, not big box.