Pizza, atmosphere and service are all very good. We've been here several times and ordered a variety of other items as well. The garlic knots are awesome - but you will scaring off vampires for awhile.
I would give them a 5 except that I use napkins to soak up excess grease off the top of the pizza - that might just be a me thing. I know pizza is greasy, but I don't really like seeing it on top of my pizza.