I'm the type of girl that really just loves food of all kinds. I can eat (and appreciate!) Joel Robuchon & Alex one day and be content to eat Little Caesars the next. I honestly think the $5 (ALWAYS hot and ready) pizzas are an insane value.
They are pretty damn tasty, easy for me to pick up on a whim, and service is always great too. For $2.75 or so I can add on a crazy pack of tasty crazy bread + sauce. For $7.75 I have tasty food to feed the husband and I for 2 days! This is one of those cases where you do NOT get what you pay for. This pizza transcends its' $5 price tag. No, it's not Settebello, but sometimes when you want cheap food RIGHT NOW this is the perfect fix.
PS - I think this place is infinitely better than Sbarro/Villa Pizza and those sorts of places.