I want so badly to give Holy Craft a higher star rating! The space is inviting and, as many other reviewers have noted, the beer selection and service are top-notch! If you are looking to have a great beer in a friendly environment, Holy Craft is a great choice.
I regret, however, that I cannot recommend the food here. Though I could see that the menu is well intentioned, all of the dishes I tried were very heavy and oily. Having had only a few bites from a tasting dinner, I left feeling rotten. If Holy Craft can make an effort to improve the quality of their ingredients and preparation, they could really be a standout in the W. 6th district. I'm rooting for you, guys!