What a cute neighborhood market! I was in the area and decided to pop in for a quick couple of items and to check it out after hearing about it for years. The store feels very homey and is extremely pleasant to spend some time in.
In addition to grabbing some cereal and yogurt (found a new Madison-based brand called Yodelay I'd never seen before from the founder of Candinas Chocolates) I visited the deli and bakery counters. From the deli I got their parmesan bowtie salad and from the bakery I got three donuts.
Parmesan bowtie salad: delicious, not oily, and the broccoli was crisp and fresh.
Triple chocolate Bavarian donut: chocolate dough, chocolate icing, chocolate creme filling. Good but not life-changing. Miller's splits their donuts in half to fill instead of injecting. More even filling throughout, but messier to eat.
Frycakes (cake ring donuts): plain and sugared. The flavor of the day was apple cider. I couldn't taste cider in either, but I'm not sure if all of the frycakes were supposed to be the featured flavor or if I missed the special one.
I've seen several reviews proclaiming Miller's the best donuts ever but for me they just weren't mind-blowing. Tasty for sure and I'd eat them again, but I wouldn't trek out to Verona specifically to get them. To be fair I did sample them a day after buying, so maybe they need to be day-of to get the full effect?
Prices are lower than I expected; being a small independent store I figured there'd be a markup, but they were on par with Copps/Festival/etc. There weren't as many noticeable in-store markdowns and sales [ex: 10 for $10] but I know they put out a circular from living on the west side.
Worth a stop if you're in the area or want to support a locally-owned shop!