I live around the corner and have been here (embarrassingly) about 12 times since they opened. I'm lactose intolerant and Yogurt is one of the few dairy foods I can have so I was very pleased when they opened. I've tried the Peanut Butter, Red Velvet, Pomegranate, Butter Pecan, Chocolate and Chocolate Mint. Butter Pecan, Chocolate Mint and Pom were the best. They have tons of toppings and everyone is super friendly! They also do a very good job keeping it clean and appealing as sometimes food bars like that can get mixed and gross.
I really want to give them a five. I've been there so much and love everything, but my one complaint is a big one. They need to do something about the consistency of the frozen yogurt. It's always runny (and not just the very beginning- but most of the whole pour almost every time). They need to turn the mixing machines colder, faster, or mix the yogurt better. Whatever would make it actually pour right. I live 2 minutes away from Yogurty's and every-time I get home to eat my tasty treat, there's a huge puddle of melted yogurt at the bottom of my cup.
Besides that, I do recommend giving them a try. The flavors are very tasty!