How have I not written a review about my favorite Italian place in Madison? Probably didn't want to get the word out but looking at the reviews, it is definitely out.
Small, rustic, no pretense but serving great food and drinks. While the items on the menu are solid (pappardelle with wild boar is always a fave), I really think the restaurant shines through their specials. My last visit was during lunch and I had an incredible gnocchi with braised lamb leg. The housemade potato gnocchi was soft and pillowy and paired well with the rich and hearty lamb.
I love that the restaurant serves as a blank canvas to the food and diners that come eat here. It is just as comfortable for a business lunch as it is for a romantic dinner.