With North of Brooklyn down the street, these guys shouldn't keep up their snobby demeanor. We've ordered take-out from Libretto at least 30+ times, have dined-in a handful of times. Has generally been decent.
My last experience was the absolute last time we will be ordering from them. Usually would call ahead for pick up, however this particular day I was walking by and decided to order at the shop and wait for my pizzas to be ready to take home. I ordered 2 pizzas. This was around 5pm on a weekday, so the bar area was still not at capacity. I asked the gentleman who swiped my credit card to PAY for the 2 pizzas that I had ordered if I could sit at the bar and order a beer, you know, while I wait for my order. I was told to stand where I was and I could order a beer and have it while standing "the bar is full service and for paying customers".
I actually found it so unbelievable, I was speechless. Just chuckled and walked out, had a really nice cold beer at the bar next door.
They will always do well, so this is essentially a waste of a review.