Don't even hesitate. Just go. I've been 2-3 times in recent years (not nearly enough) and it's stellar each time, in both food and service. The brussels sprouts are perfection in a bowl. My date and I shared those and split a burger since neither of us was starving. Now, I'm no burger connoisseur but on the rare occasion I order one I want it to be off the charts. So often at restaurants I'm disappointed by the lack of flavor in the all American burger. How hard can it be? Well, Crepe Cellar nails it with their signature burger. We ordered it medium rare, and it was absolutely, hands down, the best burger I've been served. Anywhere. Hated to share it.
The service is always good. Never fawning, always comfortably attentive, and the servers are good at making suggestions. I was considering a fun cocktail which is atypical for me, and they described it to a tee. Delish!