When I go to visit my grandma, we go to Armstrong's. The prices appear to be high when you look at the menu, but the portions are massive.
I've been coming here for years, and I've never had anything bad. Some favorites are the veal cutlet sandwich (FAV), veal parmesan, Italian hoagie, and manicotti. Every dinner comes with fresh bread, and every meal makes two full meals for me. The sandwiches are MASSIVE. You can easily just split one between two people.
The service is pretty good, but we always come at a non-peak time to avoid the wait. I've never been overly impressed by the desserts, and you really won't need one after the meal.
It's always FREEZING in here so bring a sweater if you chill easily!!