I thought I'd give this place another go, because I really want to like it. This time the husband came with and we pretty much left saying we weren't going to hurry back. I do want to say that the staff was great - we were greeted when we walked in the door and service was prompt and friendly. And I like how they've decorated the place to give it a welcoming vibe. But the food.... while my husband and I both agreed that none of the food we ordered was bad, it wasn't great either. My favorite thing was the jalapeno cheese curds. They were pretty good. My husband got a BLT, potato soup, and salad, all of which he said were just "okay." I got the club sandwich, and while the bread was pleasantly toasted, the sandwich as a whole was kind of dry, and the bacon was not crisp and had an odd flavor. And the sweet potato fries looked a little burnt and tasted dry. I took one bite of the fries and had enough. I'm sure our server would've brought a new order if I had said something, but I didn't get the impression that even cooked right they would be worth the calories.
Maybe I am just not ordering the right things off the menu.... like I said, I really want to like this place.