We came here with no expectations as we have been to other locations in Madison, but wow... we really enjoyed ourselves here. First off, we noticed a TON of families here with their kids. For us, that is a good sign. Secondly, the beer selection was pretty nice and I was able to find a few beers that I could really enjoy. Third, the food was outstanding!! The portion sizes were just right and so darn tasty!! Our daughter enjoyed her grilled cheese sandwich and fries. We liked it so much we had take out from there the next day. Although the food was good we questioned the containers they put the food in. The previous day we took leftovers back to the hotel and they gave us a nice sturdy paper/cardboard based packaging. For the carry out they put the food in flimsy clear plastic containers best suited for salads, not hot meals.
Regardless of that hiccup with the carry out (I only hope it was anyway!), we will definitiely go back if we are in the area.