Scones, scones, scones. Fav flavors: Maple nut and Coffee chip. Cranberry orange is pretty darn good too. Another one of the great restaurants in Madison and the hippie joint of Willy Street.
It's located in a creaky old town house. You walk in and order cafeteria style in a line by the door.
The seating upstairs is awesome because it has more space, a sofa, and tons of children books. It reminds me of the coffee shops in Scotland where they're in rusty old homes adding an ambiance which is impossible for new buildings.