I am convinced there is no place better in all of Pittsburgh. I've been there a hundred times in my years living in Pittsburgh, and not once have I been disappointed.
The Californian salad is my go-to; its topped with bacon, avocado, tomato, cheese, and I get it with blackened salmon- you can't even see the lettuce (ha ha) ! They do $10 bottles of wine also. The crab cake sandwiches are another one of my favorites. I would recommend doing the s'mores dessert as well.
LOVE THIS PLACE! A must if you are visiting the area.