Hostess had a horrible attitude. If the restaurant advertises that it is supposed to close at a certain time, they should stay true to it. My party walked in at 9:45pm when there were still about 5 tables in the restaurant. The restaurant is supposed to close at 11:00pm. The hostess with a look of disgust on her face says "we're closed" with no further explanation. Having this memory of this place will always leave a bitter taste in my mouth.
I've eaten here before and I can honestly say service is pretty bad and the food is not that amazing. The fish quality is poor and the food is far from special.
The oysters were enjoyable but are not on the AYCE menu.
SOHO on Jones is my go to Sushi spot in town! (Although it is not AYCE, the food is of high quality and they have an amazing happy hour and it always comes out to be the same price as doing AYCE for me).