I give 5 stars because both dining experiences were fantastic! Incredible as that seems.. Service was actually the best I've received anywhere during our first visit - my birthday with 5 family members ages 23 - 85. Waitress was knowledgable, consistently professional (despite our silliness), most accommodating (swapping wines for my indecisive mother etc.), not hovering but ALWAYS there when needed. Food did not disappoint anyone - seafood and steaks, soups and salads, and sporadic dessert (usually we're just-right full). I will keep this restaurant on my GoTo list for "special - comfortably elegant - spoiling" nights out!