More like 4.5 stars but I'll round up =)
The stone crab appetizer was delicious but I was really there to get my steak on. My filet mignon was prepared to perfection. Other high-end steakhouses can't seem to give me the medium-rare that I always request -- and so I always end up disappointed with a bland medium-well. What the heck, right??! Isn't it your JOB to know how to cook a steak?? Come on now!
But Joe's...WOW...that steak was probably one of the best I've ever had. The meat was extremely tender and cooked exactly medium-rare. There was not a single thing I did not like about it. The sides of mashed potatoes, mac and cheese, and sauteed spinach were absolutely scrumptious.
Ended the dinner with their coffee (served in a nice little mini kettle so it's actually about 3 cups) which I must say was very good as well. What makes this place even better were their more than reasonable prices and excellent service. Awesomeness.