I finally got with my patience and decided to take the plunge and check this place out. I felt the pizza was very very good, I wouldn't say it's the best, but it definitely competes with the top pie's I have had. I didn't mind the waiting much because they had very good German beer and plenty of friendly people waiting and / or working there to talk to.
I would do it again, but not as a regular thing. Beware parking can be hard to find, you can use the garage around Washington and something, sorry I cant recall the exact entrance to it, but they will validate your parking so it won't run you much after that, I paid 3 bucks.