As an ASU student I should probably be a little more well versed with the Mill Ave. scene than I actually am. I haven't spent much time down here, but I really liked the Big Bang.
Now, homegirl can get down to the rap tunes. Booty shaking is something I have no problem with, but I really like the atmosphere with the dueling pianos. Everything is really fun and lighthearted.
Get there early if you want a table because the place really fills up after 10pm. There is a cover, and they don't really offer any drink specials. But the music is really worth it.
The pianists are almost impossibly talented, and they will play anything you request. All you have to do is write your request on a napkin and send it up with a few dollars. I almost died of happiness when they played "Don't Stop Believing" by Journey.
Check this place out at least once; the experience is more than worth it!