I'd say this coffee shop lived up to the requirement. :)
They had pretty much every coffee drink you would expect as well as different milk choices including Soy. Had the sugar free syrups as well as the fresh whipped cream. I had mostly flavored drinks like Salted Caramel Mocha and Carmel Macchiato (sp?) so I'm not sure if the coffee was super quality as it is hidden by all the other flavors, but it did the job and service was friendly.
If I need a pick me up when at Wisconsin-Madison University, I'd come back here.