I can see why people like it. They brought the pub over from Ireland and stuck it in the middle of a tacky casino. Doesn't get more American than that, I suppose. The interior is pretty cool.
The food is expensive and the portions are fairly large. I had the lamb stew and it was disappointing because the broth was a broth and not a thicker near gravy like one would expect. The lamb was tender but the pieces were so large they had to be cut to eat them. (Seriously, one piece was the size of badminton shuttle). My husband had the BMT (bacon, mozarella and tomato on panini bread) and that was probably the best thing at the table. Seems surprising, but it was excellent. One person ordered the Irish nachos (fried potatoes instead of tortilla chips with corned beef on top) and those were quite good. Another ordered the steamers which were steamed mussels in a tomato broth, also good.
Our server was a little manic and laughed like a lunatic at everything we said. Granted, we are a pretty funny group (if I do say so myself) but we're not that funny. So it was a bit unnerving.
But any place that has Magner's on tap is probably going to get three stars from me just on principle.