I so wanted to give Carnevino 5 stars. The atmosphere was sublime, the service superb, and the wine list spectacular, but...
My first wine selection was unavailable. My second wine selection was sold out. After a lot of back and forth we found a bottle that was available. The food was very good, but I didn't have much to judge since I was dining early and with light eaters. We didn't order any appetizers, which is usually my favorite course. My steak was cooked and seasoned perfectly. The sides: spinach, brussell sprouts and potato zeppole were all very good. I'll have to go back in search of the missing star.