I'm really at a 3 1/2 - I enjoyed what I got, though realistically I could NEVER finish it, as the portions are huge - me and my partner shared a milkshake and we still couldn't finish it between the two of us. It tasted pretty good, though it also took a pretty long time as well. All in all, it's a nice place to go to get something super sweet once in awhile, but nothing super crazy like everyone is saying. I will say it's decorated really nicely - no wonder everyone's posting it on insta!