My husband is from NY and I am from NJ. I was sooo excited when I saw a NY bakery. I miss Terrigno's bakery in NJ and all things fresh and homemade. I was so disappointed by this visit. When I walked in I thought the display cases were empty. It was not until I got closer that I saw they were in fact full of poorly made desserts. They were so tiny and unappealing. I did not want to just turn and leave. After all, I was dying for some pastries to remind me of home. I wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt. Definitely turned out to be the worst decision of the day.
The cheesecake had a strange after taste and the peanut butter pie also had a strange after taste. It really just reminded me of freezer burn. The crust was oddly oily, yet dry at the same time. I gave it to my 12 year old son, who will eat anything, and he declined. My husband said, "my taste buds just jumped to their death." This is from a man who will eat anything with peanut butter. If you are looking for a large gob of peanut butter sludge on an awful cracker then you are in the right spot.
The only reason I am so irate is because I spent nearly $30 on this garbage. So disappointed. Not worth the time, trip or effort of parking the car and walking inside.