This place gets really busy and often has a line out the door despite being pretty big. I can't say it's that surprising though, as they have great food and good beer. I usually get the Berkshire sausage on a bun and it's delicious. My friends and I did a comparison of the regular fries and the duck fat fries, and we all (well, the non vegetarians, anyway) agreed that the duck fat fries are better. I've also had the dirty duck fat fries which are delicious (be prepared for the spicy jalapeƱos). I usually get cider when I'm there (they have a few different options), but they have a really great list of beers.
Prices for booze are average, however I think that the prices for food are very reasonable. Communal tables which I think is fun when everyone's drinking (it can get a little rowdy). I'd probably give this place closer to 4.25 stars. Staff are very friendly and I've only ever had good experiences with service.