It's probably too soon to give this place a 5, but I have only positive stuff to say.
So I was in Cabbagetown for lunch and was ready to go down to the very loud place down the street to get a coffee on my way out. When I see this place across the street with someone just sitting in front of the window sipping in what looked like peace. I hesitate for a second and decide to give it a shot.
I go in and it's small, a tidy counter with just the espresso machine. The guy is helpful in stating what their specialty is, helps me decide and here I am with a cup of cappuccino. I sip it and it's decadent. It's smooth and creamy, has a bit of bitterness for the espresso flavor. It evokes time and care put into this cup.
I pay for it and notice the (shout out to) Indie Coffee Passport and mention I've been meaning to get one. They kindly offer to refund me cup if I decide to buy then and I did! Very friendly service.
So why the 4? Well my experience was good there but i have not tried any of their foods or other drinks. I do think they could decorate a little bit more for some more personality. Next time I'll be sure to get a cup here so I can save my ears.