First let me start with telling you I am a metro area native New Yorker. My bar for what I consider a good pizza is HIGH!
Today I got the lunch combo with wings and a slice.
A real NY joint would serve their wings with blue cheese dressing and NOT ranch. LOL
The pizza in my opinion falls short of a good NYC pie like you find at Grimaldi's.
However, based on the numerous great reviews I would suggest trying this place to form your own opinion. I will likely return but I will try a hero or sub. (Sub, like hoagie is a NJ term. Most NYers might say Grinder or Wedge)