This is easily the best Italian food in the Madison area. I've never had a bad meal (or even a bad bite!) on a visit to Vin Santo.
The seafood fettucini is really heavy on the seafood (they're not trying to stiff their customers!) and they basically serve BRICKS of incredible tiramisu. Everything tastes so fresh and home-made and they offer a much more interesting menu than most "Italian" restaurants in Madison.
I'm so happy that this locally-owned business has found great success - they have lots of regulars (like I used to be!) who keep coming back for the delicious food, big servings, friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere. Vin Santo is a MUST for me when I'm in the area.