I come here every single time I'm in Toronto and it's always a five-star visit. The food is amazing and the beers are awesome too. The atmosphere has a great pub feel and no matter which room I sit in, I always feel relaxed.
I love the chicken club sandwich with sweet potato fries. The specials also rock. Last winter I had amazing mushroom gnocchi. My sister is addicted to the mac & cheese. She says it's the best she's ever had. Not my cup of tea, but the bites I had of it were good!
The service is good, although, sometimes it's a bit slow. Only real con I can say is that they charge for soda refills. But I love this place so much that it's still five stars!!