A 3.5 is adequate for Il Fornaio. I'm going with a three because "A-OK" seems more appropriate than "Yay! I'm a fan!" right now, per Yelp's rating descriptions...
...I got a bacon egg and cheese croissant. While a little pricey, it pretty much filled me up. The eggs had a strange grey color to them in spots, which should probably warrant one-star, but the cheese and bacon were plentiful enough that I think three stars is appropriate. The croissant was delicious -- flaky, soft, and super buttery. Some sort of sauce would probably have me bumping the score up by a star, but even as it was, Il Fornaio's croissant filled my belly up pretty well as my last meal from New York New York.