3.5 stars.
In fairness, I didn't get a burger because I was stuffed so I probably suffered from a case of ordering the wrong thing. Lesson learned: don't order a salad at a burger joint. My boyfriend loved his burger, on the other hand, and had the option to add a fried egg. I did notice that the burgers are a little bit on the small side for the price.
There are TONS of beer choices as well. Love that they served pizza-flavored popcorn as a free appetizer. The buffalo chicken dip was amazing and a must-order appetizer (ask for extra chips if you need them).
Again, I probably just ended up ordering the wrong thing (salad with ahi tuna) which was really bland... but worth coming here to try the burgers and shakes.