I wanted to give 4 stars as the atmosphere and food were very nice. But a couple of things brought their rating down:
1. Rather limited menu. There are some interesting dishes on the menu but its really just burgers and pizza. But then again, if that's what you want, you will really enjoy these dishes. The burgers are easily the best in Cleveland. I had the BBQ Duck pizza and it was very good. I was told that the winter menu is more expansive and so I will have to visit again to see what they have.
2. Cocktails served in plastic cups. There is no excuse for this given the drink prices.
I would definitely come back to try out their fall and winter menus. There is a lot of potential here.