I have been to Reds on several occasions and would go again. It is not perfect and a little on the overpriced side, but they do everything well. Their turkey-peameal bacon sandwich is very nice, with a healthy portion of both. The wine selection is decent, and their Caesars are exactly what you want without anything super fancy. The service is well-paced and friendly.
In fact there is not much to fault Reds for. It is a terrific neighbourhood bar/restaurant. Great for a date, a drink with colleagues after work, or to meet up with friends.