If I could give them a half, this would be a 3.5.
Food and ambiance was amazing. We walked in at 8:30pm on a Saturday and were lucky enough to get a table for 4 right by the window.
Ordered:
Clams with Fries
Fried Calamari
Flank Steak
Caesar Salad
Fried Chicken
We were still hungry after our meal so we ordered the "hamburger helper".
The food itself was amazing. Beers were flowing. Cocktail was ok, ordered the Bourbon Sour.
The reason I don't want to go 4 stars, is that after spending $300 (tax & tip included) between the 2 couples, I was still a little peckish, and by no means have a very large appetite.
So overall. Great location, ambiance, nice food and drinks, acceptable service. Just smaller portions if you're ok with that.