Wow am I on the fence about this one. Was the lobster roll fresh, meaty and delicious? It most certainly was. If you are looking for big chunks of lobster this will be your roll. If you are someone who prefers more of a lobster dip type consistency (wholey's), meaning a whole lot of mayo and smaller pieces of lobster, you will not enjoy this.
I ordered a side of tots which was a no brainer. Tot life over everything! These tots were pretty unsatisfying. They had no flavor and were pretty soggy. I'm not sure if this was due to the fact that I didn't eat them at that very moment or if they didn't cook them enough. I had a 10 minute drive back to the office before I could chow down. For $22 I wish the roll was a little bigger to hold the meaty lobster claws. I felt like it was gone in no time, which is a good thing because that means I really liked it.
I ended up choosing the Connecticut roll which is served warm with butter and lemon. I would definitely try the Maine roll which is served cold with mayo. Initially I was going to order the lobster tots, but I am happy I decided to go for the roll instead.