Gave this cafe a second chance and you know what....it redeemed itself in my book. I won't say why I was disappointed the first time because it's all about second chances here. Here's why I revoked my downvote: I can't deny that this place is cozy. To me, it feels like a 50's hobbit hole. It's warmly lit, and there's a connecting kitchen that sits between Norah's vintage shop, so naturally it feels very homey.
I ordered the keylime pie and chocolate croissant and both were down right excellent. The pie was made fresh that day in the cafe which was a plus. With the dessert, I ordered an Americano misto that was smooth and well-rounded.