I have lived in a vegetarian housing co-op for over 10 years. I am not a rabid meat eater, I have plenty of experience cooking and eating vegan and vegetarian food.
This is not a good place to eat. The only thing worth buying is the vegan cheesecake, that bumps up my review from 1 star to 2.
WAAAAY to much emphasis on "meat replacement" dishes. No, I don't want fake crab cakes. "devil wings" are gross. "unchicken" is gross.
Their non "meat replacement" dishes are underwhelming and overpriced.
For Madison vegetarian options you are better off going to a Thai/Loas place, Himal Chuli, one of the many Indian places in town, ect.. and order vegetarian options. Or come by a housing co-op for a free dinner some time.