I won't say that these are the best burgers I've EVER had (for that, Kuma's Corner in Chicago is still my go-to) but they really are quite good. And messy...which I think is important with any good burger. I ordered the Runnelstone per the waitresses suggestion and was not disappointed with my burger. I don't remember what all everyone else ordered but there were no burgers left on the table at the end of the meal.
We also ordered the sample basket to share between the 4 of us. I was with 3 other guys who, after the basket arrived, insisted that the basket wasn't big enough. I was actually really glad we got the basket because I didn't think their fries were anything great but I LOVED the fried macaroni and cheese. Plus there were fried mushrooms and fried cheese curds. I mean, why choose one fried thing when you can have FOUR different kinds in one great basket! I have to think that the others agreed with me because I don't actually remember people finishing the fries. Also, I really liked the English Garlic sauce. This sauce is on quite a few burgers so maybe this isn't the prime place to eat on a Friday night before you go out to meet a bunch of people you've never met before but we went for it anyway.
Another fun thing about this place is that they have a decent selection of beers --some Wisconsin ones and some otherwise. I would recommend the Wisconsinite if they have that when you go. Quite tasty!
If I was rating the food alone, I would probably give the place 5 stars but our waitress wasn't that great which was why I knocked off a star. Even though she provided burger suggestions, any requests for sauces or frosty glasses (even though she ASKED if we wanted a frosty glass) took a while for her to get to. I'm more forgiving if the restaurant is packed...but it wasn't.