I think I go here every time I visit the Madison area. Heck, I even went there twice on my most recent visit.
This place has great beer, good food and is a good deal. I took my girl friends out for a night and we got a round of drinks, two appetizers and entrees for under $75 for the 5 of us.
It's a good place for a crowd, but if it's a substantial group, go early or call ahead.