It seems like the reviews for this place are all across the board. Weird. My husband and I enjoyed the peanut butter chocolate chip so much, we had to go back less than an hour later to try another one (nutella). It was also late in the day and freshness was most definitely not an issue. The frosting was so light and airy; the cake was moist but not overly soft. Isn't that what a cupcake is supposed to be? Really good cake with yummy frosting on top? We especially enjoyed the ratio of frosting to cake and that it wasn't too sweet. Amazing service. Totally worth the $3.15 each.