This is an old school pizza and burger joint. People comparing McCoy's to fancier places downtown are missing the point. This is the kind of place where everyone is a regular and the staff feel like family.
I know some people who think that poutine with grated cheese doesn't count as poutine. I am not one of those people and so I think the poutine at McCoy's is fabulous - mostly based on the gravy I guess. The pizza is also excellent! I've never been a huge fan of the burgers, despite the attention they've received for the mojo burger. The onion rings are battered in front of you (not made from frozen!) and are really quite substantial.
Note: there is no seating here, and you have to stand at a counter to eat.