Tried a thin crust pepperoni with the "free" sesame seed option. The price is suspiciously low ($7 for a 14" pie, plus $1.50 per topping), and now I know why. The crust was on par with a typical frozen supermarket pizza, the pepperoni didn't have much flavor, likewise for the cheese, which was kinda greasy. The sauce was just.. forgettable. Overall, I would have given it a "C" as a packaged frozen pizza. As a fresh pizzeria pizza, it should have done much better, even at the dirtball price. Verdict: 1 star for the pizza, plus charity star thrown in for cheerful staff.
Lots of people seem to like the place (I checked the other Gilbert location's reviews) so I gotta believe they're getting the standard crust and it's gotta be a better option.