My family makes an event out of going to Remember When to see Doo-wop Dan on Saturday nights during the summer. I usually go for the small cone, which is comparable to most other ice cream place's large. The large cone is so large that is doesn't fit out of the window, they have to bring it out the side door!
The ice cream is good, the portions are generous, and the atmosphere (almost) makes you forget you are in Windgap. I highly recommend stopping by on a Saturday night to see Dan, listen to some oldies, and enjoy some ice cream!