I normally love this place, but after two not-so-great experiences, I think it's time for a break.
I've been to Cider Mill twice in the last two weeks. The first time I ate at the restaurant. Today, a group of co-workers and I called in an order for pick up. Both times I've ordered the same thing, a chef salad with ranch dressing. Both times the order has been wrong.
The first time, I got a half sized house salad instead of the chef salad. I was able to correct the server and eventually got the correct salad. This most recent time, we were rushed out the door after we paid because they were busy, so we didn't get a chance to check the order. When we got back to work, we discovered that the two chef salads we ordered (both with ranch dressing) were house salads. And only one salad had ranch dressing.
The food here is normally great, but the lack of attention to detail is what will keep me from visiting again any time soon.