This is my favorite restaurant in Shadyside and I go all the time! Love the $2 cans of beer and the food is delicious. Although a bit pricy, I don't mind going here because I know I'll always have a good time. The atmosphere is super fun - indoor or outdoor seating, bar, big TVs, corn hole, ping pong tables, people bring dogs - it's great. (also kid friendly)
As far as food, my regular is the grilled cheese with orzo as a side - really good! I've also had the cauliflower patties, pizza, and brunch. All great!