This is a very nice, hidden gem just outside of Madison. Part of the Monumental Enterprises group of stores (McFarland Liquors, Party Port, Liquor Town and Village Liquors), they have a huge private barrel program that is always growing, and they know how to pick a barrel. I've yet to be disappointed by their choices.
The inside of the store is a little tight, but the selection is top-notch and vast. Browse slowly through the aisles, you don't want to miss a great whiskey by going too fast. They also have an impressive collection of wine and beer. The prices are very fair and they aren't into the secondary market pricing game that seems to be all the rage with some store owners these days.
Nathanael is a super nice guy who wants to make sure you're getting what's the best choice for you. He's very knowledgeable and full of advice.
Cheers!